Twitter owner Elon Musk, who was born in South Africa as part of its minority white population, claimed the song promotes violence against white farmers.
It made sense under apartheid but now it would be like saying “Kill the Japs!” In San Francisco or saying “We’re going to make Charlie pay!” while talking about some immigrants from Vietnam.
You gotta tone down your shit once you’ve won, otherwise you’re kind of walking in to a crime against humanity.
It’s complicated, again it’s like saying “Kill the Japs!” Or “Kill the Bosch!” During ww2.
Yeah, I know what" boers" mean, so I got the examples . But I didn’t know the song existed, so tnx for the link!
Tbh " Killing " this or that group is just not ok, especially when it’s a rallying political song.
Just the very existence; it is just too weird to read about in this day and age.
PS: I also don’t get discrimination because of whatever color. I mean, I do get that people differentiate , which is something completely" human", imo.
For example, when I walk on the paveway someplace and I see some sketchy ppl walking towards me (no matter the color) , and they feel wrong to me, I do cross the street to the other side.
Exactly, it’s just wrong now, there’s no defense other than “We used to sing about slitting your throats in your sleep when you kept us as slaves, why can’t we now?”
…
I agree?
It made sense under apartheid but now it would be like saying “Kill the Japs!” In San Francisco or saying “We’re going to make Charlie pay!” while talking about some immigrants from Vietnam.
You gotta tone down your shit once you’ve won, otherwise you’re kind of walking in to a crime against humanity.
deleted by creator
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dubul'_ibhunu?wprov=sfla1
It’s complicated, again it’s like saying “Kill the Japs!” Or “Kill the Bosch!” During ww2.
Yeah, I know what" boers" mean, so I got the examples . But I didn’t know the song existed, so tnx for the link!
Tbh " Killing " this or that group is just not ok, especially when it’s a rallying political song.
Just the very existence; it is just too weird to read about in this day and age.
PS: I also don’t get discrimination because of whatever color. I mean, I do get that people differentiate , which is something completely" human", imo.
For example, when I walk on the paveway someplace and I see some sketchy ppl walking towards me (no matter the color) , and they feel wrong to me, I do cross the street to the other side.
I’m willing to give them some room when they were under apartheid, that’s a monstrous system and you do what you gotta.
But, they won, everybody needs to be human again.
Well, I guess that’s the whole context here. It’s something that’s happening today .
Exactly, it’s just wrong now, there’s no defense other than “We used to sing about slitting your throats in your sleep when you kept us as slaves, why can’t we now?”